Genie’s mother later recalled that Genie was not a cuddly baby, did not babble much, and resisted solid food. Ruch never stated a motive for her actions, but members of the research team believed they were due to her anger over her foster custody rejection and her perception that Children’s Hospital staff influenced the decision. I think this form of research is great and when usable it helps us understand otherwise very complicated matters. Genie’s father had an extremely low tolerance for noise , to the point of refusing to have a working television or radio in the house. Her demeanor changed considerably, and she became social with adults she was familiar with. I agree that case studies have both many strengths and weaknesses, some of which affect its validity. It is for these reasons that the case study conducted by Curtiss, Genie:

Genie returned to live with her mother, but when she couldn’t cope, Genie was placed in more foster homes where she was abused further. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour. Because he believed Genie was severely retarded he thought she would require additional protection from him, and he therefore decided he needed to entirely hide her existence. After they were discovered they were fostered by two sisters who gave them a loving home. Such an extreme level of asymmetry on these tests had previously only been documented in patients with either split-brain or who had undergone a hemispherectomy as an adult.

Genie’s mother later recalled that Genie was not a cuddly baby, did not babble much, and resisted solid food.

privation the case study of genie

studh An example of this is the study of the feral child, Genie, who spent the first 12 years of her life locked in her bedroom. Romanian Orphans Rutter et al, In the s and s many children were discovered in overcrowded Romanian orphanages with very little care provided by the staff running the institutions.

However they can pose great problems, firstly they are extremely subjective as often the researcher must interpret studdy the problem with the findings being subjective is that they can be prone to researcher bias, this is when the researcher changes the findings in order to fit their preconcieved theories.

Learning to speak after six and one-half years of silence, Journal of Speech Disorders, 7, This page was last edited on 22 Mayat Linguists also administered several brain exams specifically geared towards measuring Genie’s language comprehension.


Genie was the last, and second surviving, of four children born to parents living in Arcadia, California.

privation the case study of genie

This led to a very important study on the long term effects of privation, carried out by Hodges and Tizard Arcadia, CaliforniaU. Archived from the original on July 27, At the suggestion of Jean Butler, Genie’s special education teacher at the hospital, they screened The Wild Child during their first meeting, and the scientists later said the film had an immediate and profound impact.

Curtiss also recalled one time when, while she and Genie were walking yhe had stopped at a busy intersection, she unexpectedly heard a purse emptying; studu turned to see a woman stop at the intersection and exit her car to give Genie a plastic purse, even though Genie had not said anything. Michael Rutter wrote a book called Maternal Deprivation Re-assessed. Furthermore, although she could understand and produce longer utterances, she still primarily spoke in short phrases such as “Ball belong hospital”.

The same sort of contrast between inductive and deductive thinking i suppose. Jean Butler, who married shortly after authorities removed Genie from her house and began using her married name, Ruch, stayed in touch with Genie’s mother.

Genie (feral child)

As early as Genie scored between the level an 8-year-old and an adult on all right-hemisphere tasks the scientists tested her on and showed extraordinarily rapid improvement on them.

Privatioon later discerned that, in JanuaryGenie showed understanding of only her own name, the names of a few others, and about 15—20 words, and her active vocabulary at the time consisted of two phrases, “stop it” and “no more”.

privation the case study of genie

Over the following years multiple tests of her handedness supported this conclusion, as did observations of her in everyday situations. Evaluating the case of Genie Genie was a case study the afforded psychologists genoe overwhelming benefit of providing a unique case to study in extremely rich detail, however it must be remembered that she was just one unique individual and so the findings cannot necessarily be generalised to the whole population.

Marilyn worked with Genie to help overcome her ongoing difficulty with chewing and swallowing, which took approximately four months. Stusy Genie accurately distinguished speech sounds with her right hemisphere, they thought her language functions had lateralized there instead. Michael Rutter argued that if a child fails to develop privatin attachment this is privation, whereas deprivation refers to the loss of or damage to an attachment.


Case studies in psychological research. | daniellaking

This case study was conducted to find out the effects of privation. The pediatrician said that, although her illness prevented a definitive diagnosis, there was a possibility that she was mentally retarded and that the brain dysfunction kernicterus might be present, further amplifying her father’s conclusion that she was severely retarded.

With the exception of Jay Shurley, who felt the other scientists did not treat her as an equal, Genie’s mother did not get along well with the other researchers, some of whom disliked her due to her apathy during Genie’s childhood.

Can the negative effects stkdy privation be reversed?

Privation – Failure to Form an Attachment | Simply Psychology

Genie quickly began growing and putting on weight and steadily became more confident in her movements, and by December she had good eye—hand coordination and was much better at focusing her eyes. From the start Genie showed a small amount of responsiveness to nonverbal information, including gestures and facial expressions from other people, and made reasonably good eye contact. It is possible that the researchers had their own agendas that were not completely in Genie’s best interests.

By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use. Curtiss and Fromkin ultimately concluded that because Genie had not learned a first language before the critical period had ended, she was unable to fully acquire a language. Throughout the time scientists studied Genie, she made substantial advances in her overall mental and psychological development. Her entire vocabulary was about 20 words.

Unlike the Koluchova twins who were able to put their past behind them and have normal lives, Genie’s cognitions and emotions never developed.