Another crucial mistake made by Van Sertima relates to the detail pointed out earlier in this essay regarding the Olmec name Van, , p. It was heavily documented by both sides. The issues that exist with both arguments are inherent in the methods used to assert them and even the logic used to support them. The pseudo-scientific concept that will be discussed in this review is the narrative created by Ivan Van Sertima regarding the Mesoamerican cultures – in particular the Olmec peoples – and the purported link to the African continent before the advent of European incursion on the American continents. How about make it original? There is no relation architecturally, nor DNA wise, nor linguistically.
For instance, he states that the Malian kingdom set explorers to the New World and interacted with the native peoples extensively. The Olmec were the first ‘major’ civilization in Mexico following a progressive development in Soconusco. Peoples and Empires of West Africa. It was a name given to them by the Nahuatl speaking Aztec people, who came over years after this civilization fell, who named them the Olmecs based on who their historians knew from their own history and from what they discovered in the ruins of the long abandoned civilization. He was also asked by Congress to appear before a Congressional Committee on July 7, to challenge the Columbus myth.
Remember me on this computer. The founders of America: There is no relation architecturally, nor DNA wise, nor linguistically. The writing system in Nubian was generally the same as that of the ancient Egyptians, as they borrowed cultural concepts from each other periodically; the common writing systems were hieroglyphic, hieratic, and demotic.
The second piece of evidence, included in the book concerns comparison of religious customs of Africans and Americans. The 5 race model has been debunked by virtually every credible geneticist and physical anthropologist, however for a period of time from the late theeis th century to the early 20th century, it was accepted as a matter of fact by the academic community in the West.
Segtima evidence of this are the Islamic conquests of the late 7 th to early 8th century and the Christian conquest of Africa and the Americas in the 15 th century.
Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website. Leave your email and we will send you an example after 24 hours He attempts to use the sophistication of indigenous American civilization to validate his ideas of racial superiority. The origins of Native Americans: In other words, as previously noted, he substitutes knowledge of linguistic links and genetic relation with previously debunked phenotypic inferences — using pictures that conjure references to popular stereotypes — to make his points.
No portion of books, in part or in whole, may be produced for the purpose of inclusion in other publications without written permission by the publisher The Journal of African Civilizations Ltd. A Linguistic Look at the Olmecs.
They Came Before Columbus by Ivan Van Sertima Essay Example for Free – Sample words
During the decade of the s he broadcast weekly from Britain to Africa and the Caribbean. Two things are important to note for further reference: Another Spanish, quoted by Sertima is Vasco Nunez de Balboa, who in came upon a group of African war captives in an Indian settlement. In reality the ivsn of the statues is due to the symbolic meaning of the raw materials used in construction Van,p.
This paradigm dominates in science and public opinion ever since. Afrocentricity and the New World. Hieratic writing was a simplified versus of hieroglyphs that were used on a daily basis by scribes and the educated elite in daily situations as hieroglyphs were an art form and much more complicated than needed in the daily situation.
Peoples and Empires of West Hhesis. Demotic was a system that rose around the 8 th century BCE in Nubia, its golden era, and definitely would have shown up in Olmec and the subsequent civilizations writing systems if their sophisticated culture were truly a gift of the far flung explorers.
In discussion of yhesis topic, Afrocentrism, traditional Eurocentrism, and the roles that racism plays in the genre of pseudo-science, seryima the Afrocentric subgenre.
They Came Before Columbus by Ivan Van Sertima Essay
However the majority, if not all, of the claims made in his manuscript can be challenged using the burden ivn evidence available or completely disproven entirely. The Olmec were the first ‘major’ civilization in Mexico following a progressive development in Soconusco. As a linguist, he has published essays on the dialect of the Sea Islands off the Georgia Coast. The difference between the Eurocentric model and the Afrocentric model used by Van Sertima is that the former is used by the dominant ethnic group as a method of furthering their concepts of cultural dominance while the latter is espoused by members of a similarly marginalized ethnic group with the express intention of competing with Eurocentric ideals of racial superiority.
Ivan Van Sertima’s They Came Before Columbus: Book Review
As a literary critic, he is the author of Caribbean Writers, a collection of critical essays on the Caribbean novel. He proposes in his hypothesis that the Nubian empire of Upper Egypt and Lower Kush, respectively Southern Egypt and Northern Sudan in the present, were the founders of human civilization.
We’ll occasionally send you account related and seetima emails. That the nose on the Olmec heads are somehow indicative of a connection between Nubia and Mesoamerica.
Serima a sense, they can continue to subscribe to the beliefs that they gained through slavery and colonialism – such as Christianity or Islam – without having to worry about rationalizing continuing to follow the ideology of their captors and enslavers. The Vikings of Vinland, the peoples of the dawnland, and the Anglo-American anxiety of discovery. It is also heavily reliant on outdated sources and is bound by his contemporary notions of race and ethnicity.
There are several problems with the claims made by Van Sertima that are problematic, the least of them not being the usurping of Native American history in order to prove racial superiority. This is not new in thssis of the concept of usurping culture and history of disadvantaged people in order to bolster your own claims of superiority.